
It's that time of the year again... when some of us look with mixed feelings to the wonderful gatherings and cheers the season will bring - and along side these, the seemingly madcap shopping for gifts and the traffic that magically swells because of said madcap shopping.
Meanwhile, so of us are already thinking of where to set up our decors and Christmas trees (at least, those of us who need not think about Thanksgiving and Turkeys) - dusting them off from a year's keeping and seeing to the lights - half-hoping they're still good for another season... or if that fails, buying new sets. Then there's the test of patience as we check these lights... and set them up in the tree.
But aside from the usual countdowns, shopping and decor dusting, I believe another manner for preparing is to simply make sure that the music we would like to hear all through the season will be just a touch away... in our iPods, connected to our theater systems' speakers.
That said, I make sure I do have hours of Christmas songs... form the glorious to the happy, from the classic to the new. It is in this latter category that I search, yearly for any new Christmas CD to add to my collection... and it is in this particular month - November - that I start my searching, simply because many of the newer CDs do get released around this time.
My first review spotlight goes to David Archuleta's 'Christmas from the Heart', and let me first give you an idea of what it has... 13 songs, mostly all traditional favorites like Joy to the World, O Holy Night and Silent Night... with one piece sung as a duet with Charice Pempengco - Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas.
How does this CD feel? Note I said feel... as I believe most Christmas albums should evoke some kind of feeling with their listener. Archuleta fans may not like what I have to say though - and no, the fact that I'm a David Cook fan does not mean I'll automatically be biased against Archie. So I'll say my review (or reaction, if you like)anyway.
BY far, the album was unimpressive - at least from my expectations of Archie. Many artists come up with a Christmas album seemingly for the sake of saying they have one, and I was sorely tempted to dismiss this particular work as one such album... almost, anyway. But the song renditions are all not that bad. The previously mentioned duet with Charice does come out nicely... though I wonder if this was more because Charice was in it - and no, I'm not really that big a Charice fan either, so I'm not biased in that regard.
To be fair, David's 'O Holy Night' was good - almost getting that feeling I was talking about earlier. Now, am I being too critical - maybe, but let me explain why.
To better know where I'm coming from, let me take you - American Idol followers in general, and 'David fans' in particular, back to a time when a contestant from Hawaii named Jasmine Trias sang a song by Heart (the famous band with the two female leads)- and did a 'not too swell' number (she had a hard time with sustaining the high notes of which the song is known for). But never mind how it sounded. There was one comment by the judges that stood out.
Apparently. song selection was not just something they - the contestants, needed to consider... but there was also the fact that they had to be aware of how previous Idol contestants likewise sang the songs they chose to sing, and it may have been some time since, but the Idol judges - specifically Simon, could still remember the wonderful rendition of another Idol contestant to said song - this Idol contestant, of course, eventually won. So fair or not... Jasmine got the comparison (to Kelly Clarkson, if memory serves me right).
I have to confess to having similar comparison tendencies right now - and unfortunately for David, I'm comparing his song interpretations with the way Josh Groban sang them too.
Ah, now I'm getting some some nods amongst some readers - while Archie fans are questioning my being fair. Why do this? It's my basis to say if a song interpretation is good or bad; just outstanding or simply mediocre.
First of, Josh got those emotional buttons working with his 'Noel' album, and since most of the songs in Noel were similar to Archie's song selections - I, naturally - fairly or not, compared Archie's work to that of Josh - at least, on the emotional response thing.
And how did Archie fare?
Well let me again quote Simon when I say some of Archie's renditions - not all, mind you... seem uninspired - almost like being sung in a Karaoke. Now some of you might say - how can I say Karaoke and David in one sentence? I did earlier say it was almost uninspiring did I not? And to be fair - I've known some friends who do good Karaoke too. But we get Simon's diss, right? It meant that the song, as sung was not inspiring.
Would David even win against Josh? It will be hard to beat Josh - there is a reason why I use him as a barometer for quality songs and singing, after all. So why bother comparing the two at all, if I were to just end up dissing Archie? Well I've a surprise for you - I do prefer David's version of 'I'll Be Home For Christmas' - in a way - it was simpler, it did not sound too 'over the top' as Josh's version did with all those 'letters' from the home front and the battle field inserted in between. David's rendition was simpler - more direct to the point, so Archie fans... I'm giving this one small victory to David.
In making the songs David's - or putting a David spin, as some would say - at times, I could hear David's signature inhales - and I wonder if he really is grasping for air, could he finish the the song? I was therefore wondering if that was what made for his signature mark - it's not a David song without those gasps for air. If so, it can get distracting though. His rendition of 'Silent Night' - for example was soulful; as was his 'Ave Maria'. But... I could hear the 'breathing'. I also have some thoughts regarding 'Ave Maria' being part of a Christmas album selection - but that is another topic. Suffice it to say that David does not win any brownie points from me for his rendition of said song (and neither did Josh, by the way).
How is the CD in terms of Archie's singing? Well he does hit the right notes... but then again, studio recordings can be edited until thy get things right - right? The technical aspect is good, arrangements were cool and Christmassy (yes I know there's no such word, but I like using it) - quality was definitely implemented in the album's creation in a way that I can honestly say this sounds like it wasn't done in someone's garage.
By itself - 'Christmas from the Heart' is not bad... but it lacks some heart - some inspirational 'oomph'. Maybe David is better seen singing live than listened to? Not a chance... his old Idol studio recordings were great - so that's not it.
Did he not find a Christmas album worth doing? I can't answer that... but I hope not. Did he rush when making this? Again, I can't answer that - but it may seem that way. You see, after all is said and done - you don't have to be better than Josh, that would be too hard a goal for most - so nope... I can't ask for that. But I want my singer - when singing, to evoke a reaction from me - be it melancholy, blues, bliss, hope, happiness - or simply being merry.
If I were to use a 5-star rating manner - with 1 being 'not great' to 5 being 'totally great' - I'd give this album a '
3.5 stars' Average... with it's few brilliant moments... but not enough to warrant a rating of 4. In my recommendation to buy... sure, why not - it's still an album that's nice to listen to.
(Note: Amazon buyers have rated it a 5-star. Must be Archie fans)