
Few people can match the vocal and production excellence of Josh Groban's Christmas album 'Noel' - it's why I consider it my barometer or benchmark when thinking of 'quality' Christmas songs or albums. It may seem unfair to other artists... it may likewise seem unfair for Mr. Groban. I don't pretend to be an expert in deciding what's good or bad - but I do know what I want when I hear it.
So why start with talking about Mr. Groban? Well, I did say few, right? Here is one album that I feel matching that description. Andrea Bocelli's
'My Christmas' is a must have album. There, I've said it. It's production quality can best be discerned by listening to each song - the arrangement, the selection... and yes, definitely... the voice.
From the very start, with his soulful rendition of White Christmas, switching from English to Italian the obvious strength of Bocelli is his mastery of several languages and his seemingly effortless transitioning from one language to another as he sings without missing a beat... this lends to a universal (okay, maybe just global) theme that Christmas is definitely celebrated around the world... and this singer can definitely relate to that. BTW, I'm guessing about the Italian here, since I don't really speak the language, but if the song's other title 'Bianco Natale' is any clue... I'd guess it was Italian.
Now why'd I say global? Simple, his rendition of another classic Yuletide song, 'O Tanenbaum' starts of - rightly so, in German, then switches to English, and it's not the only song he does this too.
Andrea's other strength is his flexibility - not just with languages, but with his genre... many would say he's a classical singer... fine. Operatic in approach? Maybe so - and by the way, I don't really go for such songs or singers... and if Bocelli sang them, well then fine too... but as I said, I'm not really a fan of such genre. Luckily, Bocelli seems to have traversed such genre and found his mark continuously traversing from pop to classic.
For the most part, his Christmas songs are peppered with classical innuendos, but that's just fine - it does not come across as pretentious, nor forced. I still enjoy the songs, the rendition and... the arrangements. His 'Santa Claus is Coming to Town', for example, is sung with a choir of children... and he comes across as an adult who is reminding the children of their following some simple suggestions for when Santa comes to town - his low voice a pleasant counter to the children's high tones... that is, until he reaches a high note himself.
Another favorite of mine is his 'Jingle Bells' - see if you can place some names to the voices you'll hear him singing with.
One last thought, I believe I carped about Christmas albums carrying 'Ave Maria' as a song - not that I'm anti-Mother Mary or anything... heaven forbid, as I'm Roman Catholic, and I do admire the mother of Jesus, who is equally a central figure in the birth of Jesus... but, the song has been used in other - more sorrowful occasions, so I find it unbecoming of a Christmas tune selection. I won't blame the song - which is basically the 'Hail Mary' prayer... but I'll have to blame the practitioners using said song in sorrowful gatherings for giving me this bias. So why bring this up? Well, Josh added the song in his Christmas album - and so did David (Archuleta) for that matter, and when I hear the first few notes for said song, I simply press the 'next' button in my player whenever it comes up. So you see, even Josh could not remove form me this bias.
Well, apparently, Andrea did something different... he added into his album, the 'Lord's Prayer' - now I may say it isn't exactly a Christmas carol either, but since it's a newer - more contemporary version, it avoids the stigma of being related to less joyful practices... and yes, Andrea sings a good 'Lord's Prayer', so I let it play on.
I'm not saying I accept it as a Christmas tune, mind you... but I don't mind listening to it as part of the album. And that, ladies and gentlemen, is my one little complaint to an otherwise, near perfect Christmas album. That said, I reiterate my advice... go buy this album, and enjoy it as a worthy addition to your Christmas holiday celebration. Right before creating this review, I looked at Amazon to seek more information about the album - and it's got some sample tunes for you to listen to... so listen and see if I was right. I also came across some pictures - one where I see Andrea with one of my favorite composers/arranges - David Foster. Maybe that explains the quality.
My rating? Four and a half stars... maybe five, even, that is... if I believed it was perfect.